Two reserve studies from Amelia Island buildings, both prepared in 2024, show funding plans for components such as the roof, concrete, plumbing and waterproofing.
One building, two prices for the same roof
Amelia South Condominiums is a seven-story, 92-unit building at 3350 South Fletcher Avenue. Its reserve study is dated September 9, 2024. The executive summary lists every component the association must reserve for.
Component | Current replacement cost, 2024 study |
|---|---|
Roof | $331,740 |
Plumbing systems | $294,000 |
Waterproofing | $273,400 |
Exterior painting | $250,000 |
Structure | $150,000 |
Fire protection systems | $50,000 |
Windows | $22,500 |
Doors | $6,000 |
Total | $1,377,640 |
The study then gives two ways to fund that total. Under a fully funded plan, the association would contribute $226,777 a year, or $2,465 per unit. Under a 25-year pooled plan, it would contribute $76,000 a year, or $826 per unit.
Both plans cover the same building, roof and set of components. The difference is $1,639 per unit per year, and it comes from how the money is scheduled, not from what needs repair. A buyer who sees only the monthly fee cannot tell which plan sits behind it. The reserve study shows the two plans.
The study also shows where the building stood at that time. Its estimated beginning reserve balance was $975,729, more than the $867,175 the study calculated as fully funded. The $108,553 difference appears in parentheses in the summary, which here means a surplus rather than a gap. The study records corridor concrete repairs in 2018, east-balcony concrete repairs and stair replacement in 2023, and elevator modernization starting in 2024. It also carries a $150,000 allowance for concrete-spall repairs, marked for near-term design and competitive bidding.
All of this describes September 2024. A buyer in late 2026 would want the current budget, the current reserve balance and the minutes showing which plan the board adopted. The study tells you which questions to ask about those documents.
What a thirty-year projection shows
Shipwatch, at 1300 Shipwatch Circle on Amelia Island, is a 94-unit community built in 1975. Its reserve study is dated August 20, 2024. The Amelia South summary shows funding plans. The Shipwatch study shows the timing, meaning when reserve money builds up and when it gets spent.
- First year, 2024. The reserves start at $598,260. Owner contributions total $198,000, reserve expenses are $120,800, and the year ends at $681,443. The average contribution is $176 per unit per month.
- By 2028. The balance reaches $1,185,198, and the average contribution rises to $186.
- By 2033. Cumulative reserve spending reaches $2,792,310, and the balance falls to $149,068. The average contribution is $201.
- By 2053. The average contribution reaches $278 per unit per month.
Every year of the projection shows $0 in special assessments. In the projection, rising contributions and money saved in earlier years cover the spending. The early years list balcony work estimated at $100,800 and plumbing work at $20,000.
Why the rules leave less room to defer
Before these laws, a board could close the gap between a pooled plan and a fully funded plan by voting to waive reserves. Florida has since closed off most of that option.
The condominium statute, section 718.112, requires a SIRS every 10 years for residential condominium buildings of three or more habitable stories. For associations controlled by unit owners, budgets adopted on or after December 31, 2024 generally cannot waive or underfund reserves for the components the SIRS covers.
Under section 553.899 of the 2026 statutes, a building's first milestone inspection comes at 30 years, with another every 10 years after that. A local enforcement agency can move the first inspection to 25 years based on local conditions, including proximity to salt water.
A 2026 bill, SB 722, would have narrowed what a SIRS covers and allowed some reserve waivers. It died in committee on March 13, 2026.
Where island buildings stand this fall
The engineering work has already reached many of the island's familiar names. One Florida engineering firm's project portfolio lists SIRS or milestone work at Piper Dunes, Sandcastles, Sailmaker and Atlantis on Amelia. It describes the Sandcastles work as a building-envelope evaluation and the Sailmaker Phase 1 inspection as covering load-bearing components and foundation systems. The same portfolio lists SIRS work at Residence Condominiums, Amelia Retreat, Amelia Surf & Racquet Club, Beachside Villas and Beach Walker Condominiums. The portfolio does not publish findings or costs.
This material is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Anyone weighing a specific contract or association budget should confirm the details with a Florida real estate attorney or another qualified professional.
A question about reserve surpluses
Does a building with a reserve surplus mean low fees ahead? Not necessarily. Amelia South's 2024 balance was above its fully funded figure, but its recommended fully funded contribution was still $2,465 per unit per year. A surplus says how much has been saved so far. The study's contribution schedule shows the recommended contributions.
At John Palumbo's The Landings on Amelia River, the final six residences of Building IV are new reinforced-concrete construction overlooking the marsh. If you would like to see the residences and review the offering documents unhurried, we would welcome you. Schedule a Private Tour.